Sal Singh - Blog Posts

ashybooy

1 week ago

Andie's death ;-;

If you ain't read or watched the book/show of A Good Girls Guide to Murder, go do so and then come back here. Its worth it.

I got bored while just thinking about AGGGTM since season 2 is coming (woo!) and I realised that Andie's death was completely avoidable... that's what probably makes it so sad and everything but it could have been avoided so easy!

If Elliot didn't fuck her, she wouldn't have gone to him to blackmail him and she wouldn't have hit her head. Andie's saved there.

Lets say that still happened and she still got hurt, Andie literally turning her head would have saved her ass. Becca was mad but she felt guilty for what she did with Andie (thinking she killed her sister and disposing of her body) to the point she goes to jail for a crime 5 years later. If Andie had turned her head to look at something behind her she would have shown the wound to Becca who would have called an ambulance and got her help... then Andie could have helped her when she wasn't dizzy and moments from passing out. Even bringing her hand up to her head would have worked, showing somehow that she was bleeding to Becca would have saved her ass.

Obviously there is the other man who might have killed her (iykyk AGAD) later on but she could have gotten out with Sal by then and been safe to report that fucker! the only story in the series that could still have happened with these changes is GG,BB. Make pip obsessed with true crime, maybe she makes her podcast reporting on other cases rather than the Andie one, Connor still goes to her for help, shit still goes down!

i did just realise I had a note down somewhere to write a living au fanfic for Andie and Sal but never planned to write it... this is just connected into that somehow.

Poor Andie and Poor Singh family, they could have not been ridiculed and socially ousted if one sad man didn't fuck a minor... Elliot is why this whole shit happened (technically it was a diff man from AGAD but no spoiler).

Made everything even sadder for me, time to go sob about this more ;-;